Planning · 11 min read
Shaded garden patio with a table, the kind of outdoor space to look for on a visit

How to choose a nursing home: check the ratings, visit twice, and ask the right questions

This guide is general educational information, not medical, legal, or financial advice. Talk with your own attorney, financial advisor, or care professional about your situation. Elder Living Guide provides education and referrals; we are not a care provider, facility, agency, or medical practice.

Short answer: Start with what your parent needs now and may need later, then shortlist Medicare- and Medicaid-certified homes on Medicare's Care Compare, which gives each one an overall rating of 1 to 5 stars plus separate ratings for health inspections, staffing and quality measures. CMS itself warns that no rating system covers everything that matters, such as specialty care or how easy it will be for family to visit (CMS: Five-Star Quality Rating System), so use the stars to decide which questions to ask, not to make the choice. Then visit each home at least twice, once without calling ahead, and bring Medicare's nursing home checklist.

This page puts the official advice from the National Institute on Aging (NIA), the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) and the Administration for Community Living (ACL) in one order you can follow, with a free comparison sheet. It doesn't rate or recommend any nursing home.

Is a nursing home the right setting?

NIA says it may be time to consider a residential facility when an older person needs more help than a family member or friend can provide, and it describes assisted living as for people who need help with daily care, but not as much help as a nursing home provides (NIA: long-term care facilities). If you're still deciding between settings, read assisted living vs nursing home first. Also be clear about which kind of stay you're planning. A short stay for recovery after a hospital stay and a long-term stay are paid for very differently: Medicare covers skilled nursing facility care only for a limited time and only after a qualifying hospital stay, and it doesn't pay for long-term care (see what Medicare covers in a skilled nursing facility). If a home offers both, ask which kind of stay you're being quoted for.

Write down needs and wants first

NIA suggests two lists before you look at any home (NIA: how to choose a nursing home or other long-term care facility):

Our suggestion: put both lists on one page and bring it to every visit, so each home is measured against your parent, not against the last home you saw.

Build a shortlist

NIA suggests asking friends and family about their experience with particular facilities, and says health care providers, social workers, religious groups and support groups in your community may also be able to suggest good places. For a list of nearby homes, use Medicare's Care Compare. To find local services such as your Area Agency on Aging, use the Eldercare Locator, a public service of ACL.

Then contact each home on the list. NIA suggests asking how many people live there and what it costs, mentioning any special needs or preferences, and finding out whether there's immediate availability or a waiting list. Medicare's checklist adds a basic first question: is the home Medicare-certified and Medicaid-certified? "Certified" means the home passed an inspection by a state government agency, and Medicare and Medicaid only cover care from certified nursing homes (Medicare checklist, CMS-12130).

What Care Compare's star ratings tell you, and what they don't

CMS created the Five-Star Quality Rating System to help families compare nursing homes and to help identify areas you may want to ask about. On Care Compare each nursing home gets one overall rating of 1 to 5 stars, plus separate ratings for health inspections, staffing and quality measures. Homes with 5 stars are considered to have much above average quality, and homes with 1 star much below average (CMS).

CMS also puts a caution on its own ratings. No rating system can address everything that goes into choosing a home for a particular person, such as how much specialty care is offered (specialized rehabilitation or dementia care, for example) or how easy it will be for family to visit. Because visits can improve both residents' quality of life and quality of care, CMS says it may be better to choose a home that's very close over one rated higher but far away. It tells families to use the website together with other information, including a visit to the home and state or local organizations such as the State Ombudsman program.

The staffing rating covers more than how many nurses a home has on an average day. CMS says that since January 2022 Care Compare has posted two extra kinds of staffing information for each nursing home: weekend staffing, meaning the level of total nurse and registered nurse (RN) staffing the home provided on weekends over a quarter, and staff turnover, meaning the percent of nursing staff and the number of administrators who stopped working at the home over a 12-month period (CMS memo QSO-22-08-NH). Since July 2022, weekend total nurse staffing, total nurse turnover, RN turnover and the number of administrators who left within a year also count toward the staffing star rating (CMS: Care Compare updates, July 2022).

How we'd use the stars (our suggestion): write down all four ratings for each home on your sheet. A low rating in one area doesn't rule a home out by itself, but it tells you which questions to ask first on the visit, for example about staffing if the staffing rating is low. If a home's weekend staffing or turnover figures stand out on its Care Compare page, make your unannounced second visit on a Saturday or Sunday and ask the staff turnover question from the table below.

Read the inspection report

A star rating is a summary; the inspection report shows what inspectors found. Medicare's checklist says a nursing home must make its most recent state or federal survey report available in a public place, and that you can also find it, and older reports, on Care Compare and on most state survey agency websites. The report tells you how well the home meets federal health and safety rules. The checklist suggests asking:

Visit twice, once without calling ahead

NIA suggests visiting several homes in person before deciding, meeting the director, nursing director or other key staff, and taking a copy of Medicare's checklist to fill out at each one. On the first visit, NIA suggests looking for:

Then make a second visit without calling ahead, on another day of the week or at another time of day, so you meet other staff and see different activities. NIA also suggests stopping by at mealtime: is the dining room attractive and clean, does the food look appetizing, and can you sample it? Medicare's checklist adds things to notice on any visit, such as comfortable temperature and lighting, noise levels in the dining room and common areas, clearly marked exits, handrails and grab bars, and quiet areas for visiting with family.

If you've already toured assisted living, our assisted living tour checklist covers what to bring; the same folder works here.

Questions to ask

Medicare's checklist runs to eight pages of questions. These are a shorter set, grouped by topic, taken from that checklist (marked Medicare) and from NIA's guide (marked NIA). Questions are paraphrased lightly; the source documents have the full wording.

TopicQuestionFrom
BasicsIs the home Medicare-certified? Medicaid-certified? What state agency licensed the home and its administrator?Medicare
BasicsAre there any openings? Are there extra charges for other services, like beauty shop services?Medicare
BasicsWill the home tell you in writing about its services, charges and fees before move-in? (Medicare's checklist says certified homes must, and suggests getting the fee schedule to see what the monthly fee includes and what costs extra.)Medicare
Safety and careWhat are the home's overall, health inspection, staffing and quality measure ratings on Care Compare, and what is it doing to improve quality and staffing?Medicare
Safety and careCan my parent still see their own doctor, and does the home help with transportation for that? What hospitals does the home have arrangements with?Medicare
Safety and careHow will residents get oral care and mental health care? Are eye doctors, ear doctors and podiatrists available, or does the home help arrange them?Medicare
Safety and careHow will the home inform residents and families about its emergency and disaster plan? What happens during an infectious disease outbreak that requires quarantine?Medicare, NIA
Preventing abuseHow does the home check that it doesn't hire staff with a finding or history of abuse, neglect or mistreatment in the state nurse aid registry? What are its policies on preventing and reporting abuse and neglect, and how does it respond to concerns?Medicare
StaffHow many nurses, including certified nurse aides, are available during the day, at night and on weekends? (Medicare's checklist notes the home is required to post this.) Will the same staff care for my parent day to day?Medicare
StaffHow long have the director and the heads of nursing, food and social services worked here? How often do key staff members turn over? Is there a doctor who checks on residents regularly, and how often?NIA
RoomsIs a private room available? If my parent needs Medicaid in the future, will they still be able to have a private room? How much of their own furniture and belongings can they bring?Medicare
Daily lifeCan residents decide when to get up, go to sleep or bathe? Are there outdoor areas, and is staff available to help residents go outside? How do residents who can't leave their rooms take part in activities?Medicare
FoodIs there a choice of food at each meal? Can the home meet individual dietary needs, and can staff help residents eat and drink if needed?Medicare
Dementia careDoes the home have dementia care policies that try non-medication approaches first for behavioral symptoms? Has staff had extra dementia training? What's the home's current rate of antipsychotic medication use?Medicare
Resident or family groupIf you can attend a resident or family group meeting: what did the home change in the last year to improve residents' quality of life, and how has it responded to the group's recommendations?Medicare

If your parent has dementia, our memory care tour guide has more questions about specialized units.

Talk to the long-term care ombudsman

Every state has a Long-Term Care Ombudsman program. ACL says these programs work to resolve problems related to the health, safety, welfare and rights of people who live in long-term care facilities such as nursing homes, and that each state has an Office of the State Long-Term Care Ombudsman (ACL: Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program). CMS also names the State Ombudsman program as a source to use alongside Care Compare. Your state's program is a good place to ask about residents' rights or a concern you noticed on a visit; you can find it through the Eldercare Locator. Our tour checklist has more on who to ask outside a facility.

Costs and the admission agreement

NIA's advice: get detailed information about costs and which services are included, find out whether Medicare, Medicaid or long-term care insurance will pay for any of the costs, and ask whether the facility has a financial office that can help you see what assistance is available. Once you choose a home, read the contract carefully, ask about anything you don't understand, and read it again before signing.

Can a nursing home make a resident leave?

Only for a short list of reasons, and usually with at least 30 days' written notice. Under the federal rules for Medicare- and Medicaid-certified nursing homes, a home must let a resident stay unless the move is necessary for the resident's welfare because the home can't meet their needs; the resident's health has improved enough that they no longer need the home's services; the safety or health of other people in the home would be endangered; the resident hasn't paid, or had Medicare or Medicaid pay, for the stay after reasonable and appropriate notice; or the home is closing (42 CFR 483.15(c)). CMS's summary of resident rights adds that a home can't make a resident leave while they are waiting to get Medicaid, and that a resident has the right to appeal a transfer or discharge to the state (CMS: Your Rights and Protections as a Nursing Home Resident). The rule also says that once a resident becomes eligible for Medicaid, the home may charge only the charges Medicaid allows.

What the notice has to say. The rule says the home must tell the resident and their representative in writing, in a language and manner they understand, and send a copy to the Office of the State Long-Term Care Ombudsman. The notice generally has to come at least 30 days before the move. It can come as soon as practicable instead when the safety or health of other people in the home would be endangered, the resident's health has improved enough to allow a quicker move, the resident's urgent medical needs require an immediate move, or the resident has lived there less than 30 days. The notice must give the reason, the effective date, where the resident is going, a statement of the resident's appeal rights with the contact details of the agency that takes appeals and how to get the appeal form and help filling it in, and the contact details of the state ombudsman office. When the reason is that the home can't meet the resident's needs or that their health has improved, the resident's physician must document it in the medical record. If the resident appeals, the home may not transfer or discharge them while the appeal is pending unless not doing so would endanger the health or safety of the resident or others, and it must document that danger. The home also has to prepare the resident for a safe and orderly move (42 CFR 483.15(c)).

Hospital stays and holding the bed. Before a nursing home sends a resident to the hospital or on therapeutic leave, the rule says it must give written information about the state's bed-hold policy, if there is one, and its own policy on coming back, and at the time of the transfer it must give written notice of how long the bed will be held. If the hospital stay runs past the bed-hold period, the home's written policy must let a resident who still needs its services and is eligible for Medicare skilled nursing facility or Medicaid nursing facility services return to their previous room if it's available, or to the first available bed in a semi-private room. If the home decides that a resident it sent to the hospital can't come back, that is a discharge, with the same notice and appeal rights (42 CFR 483.15(d) and (e)). This is different from Medicare ending its coverage of a short skilled nursing stay; for that notice and its fast appeal, see can you appeal if care is ending too soon.

Our suggestion, not CMS's: if a notice arrives, write down the day you got it, compare the reason it gives with the list above, and contact the state ombudsman office named in it, which should already have a copy. Ask the appeals agency named in the notice how long your parent has to appeal. If the notice is about unpaid bills while a Medicaid application is pending, tell the ombudsman and the home about the application in writing. Appeals go to the state, so for advice on your parent's case talk with your own attorney.

Free side-by-side comparison sheet

Download the free nursing home comparison sheet (CSV). It has one row per home and columns for certification, the four Care Compare ratings, whether the last inspection's citations were corrected, the abuse icon, both visit dates, openings or a waiting list, a private room if Medicaid pays later, and notes. It opens in Excel, Google Sheets or Numbers, and it's blank: no home names, no ratings.

Made-up example

Made-up example (not a real family or real nursing homes). A family compared two certified homes after their father's hospital stay:

On the sheetHome A (40 minutes away)Home B (10 minutes away)
Overall rating5 stars4 stars
Staffing rating4 stars3 stars
Last inspection citations corrected?YesYes, one still being fixed; they explained the plan
Unannounced visitNot done yetDone at dinner; calm dining room, staff knew residents by name
Private room if Medicaid later?"Depends on availability""Depends on availability"

The family didn't pick by stars. They booked the unannounced visit at Home A, asked Home B for its posted night and weekend staffing, and talked about how often each of them could realistically visit a home 40 minutes away, the trade-off CMS itself mentions.

Next steps

How this page is made

Carter Hockinson, the editor of Elder Living Guide, built this guide from the National Institute on Aging's guide to choosing a long-term care facility and its overview of long-term care facilities, the CMS Five-Star Quality Rating System page, Medicare's nursing home checklist (CMS-12130, November 2022) and ACL's Long-Term Care Ombudsman Program page. All five were checked on October 20, 2026, and each fact is cited where it appears. The order of steps, the advice on using the stars, the comparison sheet and the example are our suggestions, labeled as ours; the example uses made-up homes and ratings. We didn't visit any nursing home for this page and don't rate or recommend one. On October 30, 2026 we added the section on when a nursing home can make a resident leave and the note on the signature line in the costs section, from the federal nursing home rule on admission, transfer and discharge rights (42 CFR 483.15 on eCFR, last amended May 10, 2024) and CMS's summary “Your Rights and Protections as a Nursing Home Resident”, both checked that day; the suggestions on what to do when a notice arrives are ours. On November 1, 2026 we added the note on arbitration agreements in the costs section, from the federal rule on binding arbitration agreements in nursing homes (42 CFR 483.70(m) on eCFR, section last amended June 21, 2024), checked that day; the suggestion on handling the agreement is ours. On November 9, 2026 we added the note on weekend staffing and staff turnover in the star ratings section, from CMS memo QSO-22-08-NH (January 7, 2022) and the CMS fact sheet “Updates to the Care Compare Website July 2022,” both checked that day; the suggestion on when to make the second visit is ours. Rules and programs differ by state, so check with your state's survey agency and ombudsman program.

Keep reading: Types of senior care compared · How families pay for senior care · Senior care planning: the complete family guide

Elder Living Guide provides education and referrals. We are not a care provider, facility, agency, or medical practice.